Update on the Deindexing Situation (or; OW will never be indexed again)


So... if you'll remember from some of my recent posts, I was told by itch that "my game doesn't look deindexed/show any indication of having its visibility affected" and that "it's probably some kind of search bug." Well, it turns out that this was, in fact, a lie, and OW was deindexed on purpose. I am unsure why I was lied to and why it took me so long and finally having to hail Mary post on Reddit to get the truth, but it is what it is. 

OW was deindexed because of its content warnings. Basically, whatever AI bot they use to scan game pages didn't like my warnings and arbitrarily decided that such warnings make it an 18+ NSFW game. And because I have not labeled OW as an 18+ NSFW game, it was automatically deindexed.

Though I tried to appeal this, I was ignored. (And also got humiliated on Reddit.)

I do not want to label OW as an 18+ NSFW game, mostly because it is not, in fact, an 18+ NSFW game. While it does have mature themes and sensitive content, it is not an NSFW game (no nudity, no sex) and I have always likened it to an R-rated movie or M-rated game. Not only that, but I feel like labeling it as such would be rather antithetical to the core themes of the game (that being the pressures of sex on an asexual person).

But even in addition to this basic principle of the matter, marking it as NSFW would simply be bad for the game, players, and me as the dev: 

  1. Marking it as NSFW would make it so that it only appears in NSFW-specific tags. Players use these tags to find 18+ erotic content. They will assume my game has 18+ erotic content because of the tag and be disappointed. It will also simply be confusing and players won't know if my game actually includes NSFW content or not. This is bad for players trying to find content that they actually want to play and would lead to a bad and confusing user experience.
  2. Marking the game as NSFW would mark my entire account as NSFW and my profile and everything would be restricted (inaccessible in the UK for instance) and I would not be able to turn off seeing NSFW games when I use itch browsing functions. Many NSFW games on itch have graphic nudity in their cover art. As an asexual dev myself, this would make me really uncomfortable. (Not saying this is true of all aces, but it would be for me, and probably many other allo devs who just don't want to see giant uncensored dicks whenever they want to browse games on itch LOL).

(if OW is labeled as having "sensitive content," only logged-in users who have checked this box will be able to see it, and it will only show up in "NSFW" tags)

The thing that bothers me the most is that this decision was made without anyone even playing the game. It was made simply because of the context-less CWs I included on the game page (which I have always been purposefully extremely thorough with and even more intense with than they need to be because I want to make absolutely sure people don't run into something they're unprepared for). This directly contradicts Steam, which did a complete manual review of the game, including asking for save files so they could play through and review all the sensitive content. And after that, OW was not labeled as an adult game on Steam.

Itch does not currently have a way to separate "sensitive content" from "adult content." I'm told to tag my game as having "sensitive content" but doing so marks it as an 18+ NSFW game. This shouldn't be so as these are entirely separate things -- people are getting deindexed for having things like child abuse, domestic abuse, SA, and the like in their content warnings, but these things don't make a game "adult," and they certainly should not be included in NSFW tags. If itch is going to rigorously uphold this rule about sensitive content, then they need to separate it from "adult content."

Though another issue is the fact that itch DOESN'T rigorously uphold it. They only care if their AI bot flagged for your game. Because if you go and check out even the top two pages of VNs on itch, you'll find 20+ games with CWs at an equal level to or even more intense than OW (some that even literally say 18+ or adult only):

(shown extremely blurred because I don't want to show actual games as none of them have done anything wrong, I just want to make a point about CWs and how the same types of CWs that my game was flagged for very common across the site)

If itch cared about games being incorrectly flagged, then surely all these games would be deindexed because of their "sensitive content," too...? Right? Hahaha... hahahaaaa...

So why is it just me and a few other devs????

Hmm. Questions to ponder.

I'm not saying any of these should be deindexed or be forced to tag themselves as adult. I think that devs themselves reserve the right to decide if they need to tag their games as 18+ NSFW or not on their own, since itch doesn't have a manual review and thus cannot determine whether a game needs to be "adult" or not. (Though even something like that could still be biased.) I'm simply pointing out the extreme disparity here, where my queer horror game got deindexed for being clear and thorough in its CWs despite every single page of games on itch being filled with other games with the same types of CWs.

It's incredibly frustrating. Even more so when I was lied to and ignored for months when trying to inquire about it.

Alas.

Soooo... yes, it appears that OW will never be indexed again.

I'm probably also going to remove the downloads once the remaster is live on Steam. I'll keep the game page up for posterity's sake, especially since I love going back and reading everyone's kind words about the game. But I'll likely just remove the downloads themselves or have them redirect to Steam or something, since the game page is deindexed anyway (and my entire account is probably marked as "high risk" now lol).

Just really frustrating all around.

Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

(+1)

if you would like I could upload the ZIP on my archive.org page

Ahhh no please don't do that! That would make me feel a bit weird. Thank you for the offer though!

yw

have you considered gamejolt?

(+3)

I hate this. :( Our Wonderland is one of the best and most memorable VNs I've ever played. I'd play it at night and wake up the next morning thinking about it. It's an incredible work of art. Yes, it has what I would call "strong themes" involved, but nowhere near the kind of content that would warrant a perma de-index. That's just....it's mind boggling, honestly. Meanwhile, I'm literally jump scared on the daily by explicit cover art for some pretty hardcore VNs and they're just...like you said, RIGHT there for everyone to see. I really don't get it. There is certainly a double standard and you got the shaft. The system is definitely broken. Really sorry you have to contend with this. 

(1 edit) (+2)

this is so damn frustrating and im so tired of these sites relying on inconsistent ass ai moderation -_- i understand itch is a smaller staff and they dont have a ton of resources but ive always found their search subpar and in need of improvement tbh... and this only makes things more difficult for everyone. i keep "sensitive" content OFF by default not because im against nsfw content at all, i play eroge frequently in fact! but because theres SO MUCH and a lot of it isn't interesting to me at all and its so hard to filter for anything on this site that it's easier to knock out the entire category and only turn it on when im specifically interested in eroge...

what i find silly is knowing my own game never got deindexed despite it having a lot of similar warnings particularly for body horror and graphic violence? if it's simply a matter of slightly different wording (or different time or the planets align the wrong way... i dont know how the bots work lmao...) then it's just ridiculous and only goes to show how ineffective using an AI moderation is, at least on it's own. these things should always be looked over by a human to verify, at the very least they could have looked at the actual text to see that the warnings are for the blood/gore/body horror. if you did a proper rating test (like for google play) it would absolitely wouldn't get higher than M rating. this site is FULL of horror games and like half the games here should be slapped under the adult content label and treated as R18 in that case >.<

(+1)

Unfortunately, it was looked at by a human, because I had some of my CWs thrown back in my face (ones for "sexual violence," "unwanted sexual advances," "disturbing content," etc) and was told to explain myself πŸ₯΄ This is what led to me being called a weirdo and a freak on Reddit lol

But even after I appealed that no actual SA takes place in the game (it's more a threat but nothing happens in the end because it's stopped) and that the unwanted sexual advances was referring to things like the MC being kissed sensually and getting uncomfortable because he's asexual so he eventually pulls away, it didn't matter and I was ignored. It didn't matter that there's no actual nudity or sexual content in the game -- because of these CWs it must be NSFW.

I think that a lot of the flagging must come down to specific wording: I see other games with CWs like "unwanted advances" and "dubcon" that don't get flagged for instance. Though for some reason straight up labeling your game 18+ doesn't get flagged LOL Some devs also put their CWs only in an external link or in an image, which keeps it from getting flagged.

It's just really frustrating all around and starts to make it feel really targeted πŸ˜… And likely nothing is going to change about how it works, you just have to be careful and hope you don't get flagged for the way you worded something.

And yes I agree -- there's certainly nothing in OW worse than what's in The Letter for instance, which is an ESRB rated M VN:


 And it definitely definitely is no worse than M-rated AAA games like Baldur's Gate, GTA V, The Witcher, etc that have straight up nudity and sex LOL 🀣

Bah.

(+1)

thats so dumb and weird and is like.. the response to that is the exact kinda thing i feel makes a lot of ppl feel really reluctant to properly warn?? like its counterproductive πŸ˜­ Like I was SUPER hesitant to tell anyone any specifics about Alex's intrusive thoughts at first (And I still am really cautious about talking about it on my bigger accounts because of how weird people get about sexual themes...) bc I got paranoid that people would flip out and think I'm nasty for writing him having sexually violent intrusive thoughts u_u even though I felt like it made his arc way stronger and his plot wouldn't make sense if i avoided sexuality at all.

I think it's a lot of wording issues too yeah. I actually still need to add those to my CWs too (and I actually do have a warning for artistic nudity lmao...) but I always had a short summary and the full scope outside the site since I wanted to have extra detailed ones to keep people safe. and now that theres all these nsfw/adult content bans I avoided putting "adult" sounding terms on my pages too. I remember actively grimacing at the idea of adding any of the sexual/suggestive content warnings into the main store pages in case it was taken as "theres full on graphic undeniable sex scenes" instead of "sad catholic guilt and also an old lady is nude at some point for symbolism purposes" πŸ˜­ 

(+2)

Carrot I am SO fucking sorry πŸ˜– as a fellow dev with a wrongly deindexed game, I don’t even know what to say. But I fully and 100% support whatever decisions you make moving forward with OW and any other titles, and I’ll gladly stay angry for you 🫢🏽

(+1)

🫢🫢🫢

Thank you so much, Gemini πŸ’•

Just wish there was more consistency and clarity (and transparency) around all these things, because the disparity is what makes it feel especially targeted πŸ₯΄

(+2)(-1)

Of course itch lied about it. Of couuurse. Integrity? What's that? For all the problems Steam does have, at least they do actually manually review games instead of going by an AI-read description and then not budging?! Absurd!!

Plus the double standards of a bunch of games being fine to host without problem even though they have THE SAME STUFF. Don't trust a bot to do stuff when it comes to people's work and then blindly trust its decision. 

Also, really really appreciate the consideration towards us in the UK. Like it's actually abysmal, we can't access SO MUCH because. What. Of  "children". We all know it's not really for the sake of kids, and we don't blame them. Those who have been adults for a long time (me and so many others) can't access things marked adult on itch because itch can't be bothered to deal with the faff that is age verification, so it's easier to just lock british people out and pretend they don't exist. Thank god for vpns, honestly... At least Steam (quite annoyingly, but at least it's a way) requires the use of a credit card to prove age, then you can view everything.

Sorry, got rambling about it. This whole debacle with collective shout and the payment processors is actually horrible and they need a slap. 

My ass WILL be playing the remaster on Steam! (And if you need the use of a Steam Deck to check compatability/get it deck verified, I offer my own up)

It would be a shame to lose the older versions, so having them on patreon would be a nice way around that πŸ₯ΉπŸ’– 

(+1)

The fact that there's literally games that say 18+ and that's somehow totally fine but my game is not is what really gets me 🀣 Ahhhh... alas. This whole fiasco since last summer has honestly just drained me so much. The one good thing that's come out of it is the Steam opportunity though because of BÑiYù's kindness, which is why I'm so so hopeful that it can go well.

WEEP I don't think I knew that you were in the UK??? I'm so sorry, that whole ordeal has sounded SO miserable 😭 What an absolute crock. Considering how many other countries are champing at the bit re: age verification I'm even more worried it could expand further and even more countries would simply be blocked on itch if your account is marked πŸ˜‘ Just ridiculous. Well I'm glad you can still visit my page πŸ’• I would hate for anyone to get straight up blocked for something so stupid...

Yeah I'll probably leave the OG version on Patreon! That way it's not like, super obvious and getting in the way of ppl just trying to search for the game (because I don't want it to be confusing as to what each version is), but it would still be accessible for ppl in the community that want it for whatever reason.

(Also thank you πŸ’• And actually if you're serious about that Steam Deck check I may take you up on it, as I would at least like to know that the game can be run on it without any issues before release... πŸ˜‚)

The double standards of it all... I wouldn't wish deindexing on anyone but the wishy-washy inforcement of the 'rules' is ridiculous.

When the online safety act first started happening it was honestly very scary. There are way more problems here that should be focused on than restricting and policing what we do online, but what can we do... (shrug) Y'know, aside from basically always having a VPN on lol

(I am serious! A lot of visual novels run very well on it without much tweaking, but sometimes the controls auto-map to strange options, like one I was playing earlier takes screenshots when I accidentally use the left stick to try and move over on the little mini-menu options to save...)

It's been very obvious to me since this entire collective shout situation started that queer people + other marginalized groups are the main target. It's not about what is or isn't "nsfw," at least not really. It's just about shutting up minorities and punishing us for daring to share our creative works at all.

I'm disgusted (but not surprised) that you were lied to. I'm disgusted (but not surprised) that you are now being ignored. I genuinely hope Steam treats you and your game with more respect. This childishness from itch is just a giant headache all around. I'm very sorry that you weren't taken seriously, you did not deserve that disrespect at all </3

(+1)

Thank you for the kind words and the well wishes. I also hope the Steam release can go better -- since this happened, my whole account here on itch has seen a massive slump in visibility and it's been really discouraging as someone who's been really trying to make a little community on here with my games. It just makes me really sad. But I hope I can still find ways to share my games places they can actually be seen πŸ’•

Itch is genuinely so aggressively unfair!


It would definitely be sad to see the original pre-remaster version go. We'd be loosing some of the game's history. At the same time, I completely understand if you have to, it's your decision


I can't wait for the steam release so you can finally be free from this 

Tbh I'd been planning to eventually archive the original anyway -- I think it will create some confusion when trying to search for the game and not knowing which is which etc. I'd rather there just be one main version out so it's more clear for people just stumbling on or looking for the game for the first time. Though that was when I planned to still release the remaster here, so it would have maybe been more gradual and having both versions on the page for a while before getting rid of the old one. 

Now especially after all this I would just rather get rid of it. Feel like it's causing me nothing but bad thoughts and dredging up anxiety. I'll probably still leave it up on Patreon though, we'll see.

I'm really sorry. This is absolutely awful. I can't believe Itchio just lied (ok well).  I'm hoping for the success of your steam release T_T

(+1)

It's ridiculous amounts of frustrating and feels like a kick in the teeth tbh. Thank you though πŸ’• I really hope it can, too!

(+4)

i'm kinda lost at this point, do any of y'all think that if/when Visa and Mastercard (or Collective Shout) stop fucking shit up, this is still gonna stop as well? Or is this just permanent now or something? Cus i haven't heard about them for a while now

(+4)

It seems to just be a permanent thing at this point. There haven't been any updates or progress since it happened last year at least -- adult games still cannot be paid without being deindexed, etc. And there are still many SFW devs deindexed without answers., too.